Superbrand
 
  LET'S CATCH CRIMINALS, NOT JUDGE THEIR VICTIMS
  by Pritish Nandy on Wednesday March 19 2008.
Fiona MacKeown wanted to settle down in Goa and run a pony-trekking business. I may not exactly approve of pony-trekking but I can imagine the circumstances under which a 43 year old woman with nine children from five different fathers and living on welfare in south-west England in a down and out caravan would like to migrate to a sunny beach where the winters are not so harsh and the people are warm and welcoming.

Yes, Goa is paradise on earth. Without doubt. But there's this dark underbelly of Goa that Remo sings of and people talk about in hushed whispers. Of drugs, rave parties, undisclosed rapes, murders that go unreported because the cops are so easy to buy off. There are whispers about Russian mafia buying off vast tracts of land, Israeli drug dealers, Uzbek prostitutes, and Chinese criminals trying to muscle their way in to sell their own dangerous cocktail of crime, corruption, cheap products. No one knows how much of this is true but, yes, one sees a lot of firangs around, having a good time and wanting to settle down on the sun drenched beach, forever. Just like Fiona did.

Scarlett's dead but what saddens me is that instead of catching her murderer, everyone (including the Goa politicians, the cops and the British media) are more anxious to discuss Fiona's parenting lapses and how free living British mothers have no business complaining when their kids get into trouble. Reports claim Scarlett did drugs. Fiona denies it. The cops first claimed she died ODing. Then, when Fiona refused to give up, they did another autopsy and found she had been brutally raped and left to die. There's an eye witness too, another tourist who's too scared to come back and testify.

What should be under public scrutiny is the crime—the brutal murder of a 15 year old. Not her life style. Nor how many lovers her mother had. This is typical of the way we treat every rape and molestation case. This is the way sex crimes try to escape the law, by casting vulgar aspersions on the victim and making rape and molestation look inevitable. The idea is to make us believe that a girl who does drugs or has underage sex is a deserving victim. Why? Why do we want to deny a woman who is not virtuous in the conventional sense the right to choose who she has sex with? Surely even a whore can decide who she wants to sleep with. Raping a middle aged woman of easy virtue is no less a crime than raping a teenager—the difference is only in your mind and mine, a difference that defence lawyers and corrupt cops try to exploit.

That's what's happening to Fiona. The spotlight is being nudged away from the crime to the victim's personal life, and her mother's hapless background. So what if Scarlett smoked hash? So do millions of other youngsters, including possibly your children and mine. Some ruin their lives by doing so. But most give it up after a few tries and go back to living a perfectly normal life. So what if Scarlett had sex at 15? So do millions of other kids everywhere. It doesn't make them any less virtuous. And it certainly doesn't mean any thug can have a go at them. So what if Fiona left Scarlett with a friend to go off to Karnataka with her other kids? Does careless parenting, even assuming this was such a case, mean that Fiona deserves what she got? So what if she lives on welfare back home in England, in a caravan surrounded by mounds of empty beer bottles and filth? Does it mean she lives a reckless life and her children are unloved, uncared for? So what if Fiona had many lovers and nine children? Does it really matter what her personal life is or was or could be? What matters is that Scarlett was killed in cold blood and the cops tried to hush it up.

What annoys me and should annoy us all is this constant moralising that goes on around us. Everyone is judging everyone else, usually for all the wrong reasons. This is what is leading to such a spurt in crime. All kinds of criminals are getting away.

Title
Name
Comments
 
Code Image - Please contact webmaster if you have problems seeing this image code Load New Code
 
        
nice blog
nice blog
nice blog
Tuesday, August 19, 2008 Top

1
Blog Archive
 
2010
   

IN PURSUIT OF FAME

THE CURIOUS APPEAL OF SALMAN KHAN

THE RISE OF $ BILLIONAIRES

THE RIGHT TO PRIVACY

THE DEFICIT OF TRUST

A NATION OF BANS

LEARNING TO SAY SORRY

A BANDH THAT WORKED

THE MAKING OF GOTHAM CITY

THE PRICE OF HONESTY

LEARNING STARTS WITH IRREVERENCE

The Power of No

THE AGE OF THE FORGETTABLE

A VERDICT FOR CHANGE

THE IRRELEVANCE OF THE BJP

FOLLOW THE MONEY!

WHERE HAVE ALL THE GOOD GUYS GONE?

WILL THE NET DISTORT HISTORY?

THE BLINDING POWER OF BLACK

THE WONDERLAND THAT'S INDIA

THE POWER OF CONTROVERSY

THE BUDGET AS TAMASHA

THE GIFTING OF LOVE

THE RHETORIC OF CHANGE

THE IMPORTANCE OF AWARDS

RENEWING THE CHASE FOR EXCELLENCE

The Art of Living

MYSTIQUE OF THE WHITE SHIRT
   
2009
   

EXIT, THE TALL, DARK, HANDSOME STRANGER

FLEEING THE PRISON OF TECHNOLOGY

LET’S GET BACK TO MAKING MOVIES

The Murder of a Sportsman

LETTERS, TWEETS, ONE PAISA SMS

LET’S STOP JABBERING ABOUT 26/11

WELCOME TO THE AGE OF EXCESS

WHO IS A HERO?

WHAT IS STAR POWER?

WHY STABILITY HAS AN EDGE OVER CHANGE

THE CHOICES WE MAKE

THE ART OF MANAGING FAME

WHY DO WE WANT OUR LEADERS TO BE SO BORING?

THE INQUISITIVE INDIAN

WORDS DIE. SO DO MOST THINGS

THE NEW POLITICS OF AUSTERITY

DO WE ALL HAVE A SELL-BY DATE?

THE POWER OF BREVITY

DOES GOOD STAND A CHANCE AT ALL?

THE PHATAPHAT GENERATION

MORNING SICKNESS NOW HITS US ALL

THE ONLY GENIUS I EVER KNEW

A FREE NATION IS UNAFRAID TO LIVE OUT ITS DREAMS

THE INDISCREET ART OF DADAGIRI

TRUTH OR DARE?

WELCOME TO THE AGE OF BLACKMAIL

END OF A ROMANCE

A CHANGING WORLD ORDER?

EXIT THE COMMISSARS

DID WE ACTUALLY VOTE FOR CHANGE?

HYSTERIA IS NO ANSWER TO TERRORISM

A NEW DEAL IN THE NEW YEAR?
   
2008
   

WHAT SHALL WE REMEMBER 26/11 FOR?
GRIEF, ANGER, OR CHANGE?

IS THIS THE CHANGE WE ASKED FOR?

GET THESE NETAS OFF OUR BACK!

THE KILLER APPEAL OF BAD BOY MARKETING

THE PLAUSIBILITY OF HOPE

THE ART OF INTOLERANCE

WAITING FOR A MIRACLE

PAPA DON'T PREACH

FIVE BLIND MEN AND MY HINDOOSTAN

THE ART OF THE CON

DO WE REALLY KNOW HOW TO FIGHT TERRORISM?

TIME TO REJECT OLD PLATITUDES

WAITING FOR A MIRACLE

LIVING ON THE EDGE

MANMOHAN SINGH'S LAST CHANCE

NOT JUST INFLATION, A NIGHTMARE

TIME FOR ANGER MANAGEMENT

THE LEGEND OF CHE

A STAR IS A STAR, NOT SUPERMAN

WINNING IS NOT ABOUT MONEY

LET'S LOOK FOR EASIER SOLUTIONS

SOFT POWER UNITES WHAT POLITICS DIVIDES

TIME TO SIGN THE NUCLEAR DEAL

A PIRATED COPY OF FREE INDIA

TOO MUCH TAMASHA KILLS THE GAME

IPL AND A THROWBACK TO OLD LOYALTIES

THE MOCKERY OF FIGHTING INFLATION

LET'S CATCH CRIMINALS, NOT JUDGE THEIR VICTIMS

THE POLITICS OF PROFLIGACY

APNA SAPNA MONEY MONEY

THE TRAGEDY OF REGIONAL POLITICS

WHY TAX PAYERS HATE PAYING TAXES

LOSING BY THE RULE BOOK
   
2007
   

WINNING IS EVERYTHING:

CHANGING STATUS SYMBOLS BY PRITISH NANDY

WHY TASLIMA NEEDS YOUR SUPPORT BY PRITISH NANDY

INDIA NEEDS THREE CRICKET TEAMS by PRITISH NANDY

STEP OUT OF THE PANIC ROOM OF THE PRESENT

PRITISH NANDY'S BEST INTERVIEW EVER

THIS NONSENSE ABOUT BIG FILMS