Superbrand
 
  THE BUDGET AS TAMASHA
  by Pritish Nandy on Thursday March 04 2010.
We love being entertained. The sillier the flick, the more we flock to it. From Laxmi Mittal to Lord Meghnad Desai, everyone’s a fan of Bollywood. It’s getting bigger, brighter, stupider. But who cares? We are busy boasting about size, scale, budgets and star fees as the average shelf life of our movies has dropped to a week and a half, and the House Full sign is as rare as the unicorn.

Our festivals are also becoming tamashas. They have less to do with faith and religion, more to do with spectacle and celebration. There’s no scope left for intimate conversations with God. It’s all about fancy rituals and noisy worship, lots of song and dance. The same is true for politics. The nation’s biggest spectacle today is the elections. For weeks before that, movie stars, singers, squint-eyed comics, poets, musicians and charismatic criminals crisscross India selling ideology and candidates to mesmerised audiences. We no longer vote for issues. We vote for the spectacle. If you can’t bring a star on your campaign trail, you may as well not contest.

We are converting everything into entertainment these days. Take sports. Cricket’s no longer the charming but dreary game it once was. It’s a carnival today spanning live events with cheerleaders, round the clock live TV coverage, branding, merchandising, million dollar sponsorships and (ofcourse) illegal gambling. Even the village idiot knows where the maximum money’s made. Those who drive the game now are the ubiquitous movie stars, businessmen and politicians. The IPL has taken away forever whatever little claim cricket had left to sporting activity. Now it’s full on tamasha and the stakes are huge. My guess is you will soon see many more sports emulate this profitable model. The next step will be to legalise gambling. With the BCCI’s enormous clout I don’t see that as a problem.

But the big new tamasha on the scene is the Budget. For weeks before, the media builds it up to look like the year’s most dramatic event. Yet nothing really happens on Budget day that’s ever impacted our lives for the better. Yes, sometimes it hurts us bad but then we attribute it to the evil ways of politics and move on with our lives. You can chuck as many stones as you want, burn as many buses you choose to. But that’s not going to make the slightest difference. The vested interests at play are far too strong for the Government to make changes for our sake. Every decision taken in the budget is meant to benefit someone. The big boys of the corporate world play these games either directly or, when that’s not possible, through their political friends who proffer all the apt ideological arguments required for these decisions. Only an ass believes the Budget is meant for you and me. It’s meant for the guys who keep the ruling party in power. The Budget’s their payback time.

The fun is in watching how this non-event has become such a fantastic tamasha. TV has taken my friend Palkivala’s place. The great Government PR machine works overtime through its pet journalists to create the right atmosphere for tough decisions to be taken. Weeks before the Budget you begin to see articles argue with great ardour that difficult decisions are critical for the nation and the Government must not shirk from taking them. As Budget day comes closer, the stories get more high pitched. Keep a careful watch and you will know exactly what’s likely to happen. All the clues are there over the preceding weeks. Ultimately, the silliest decisions taken, from reducing the price of latex to the tax on balloons, appear to be in the nation’s vital interest. You can scream your lungs out but the nation has been already primed by the media to welcome the Budget. If however the outcry is too much or the stock market suddenly collapses, Plan B comes into operation. A few token rollbacks will instantly show how responsive the Government is to public opinion. It’s all pre-planned.

That’s why the tamasha. It masks the serious issues and allows us the pleasure of dumbing down everything to the level of popular, brainless entertainment. Our movies have gone that way. Theatre too. TV as well. Our sports, our politics. Why not our Budget? Why not environmental issues? Why not conduct foreign affairs as tamasha? Why not reduce everything to nonsense? That will ensure the Government can get away with anything. Farmers are committing suicide in Vidarbha? Let’s build a huge Shivaji statue in Mumbai, in the middle of the Arabian Sea. A few more million families have slid below the poverty line? Let’s offer 3G to the nation. Cost of basic food items going up? No issue. Let’s make cell phones cheaper. Healthcare’s unaffordable. Hospitals are a mess. Let’s make balloons excise free. Jobs are vanishing? No problem. Let’s allot Rs 3000 crore in the Budget to give everyone an ID card. Every problem has an equal and irrelevant response in our time.

Title
Name
Comments
 
Code Image - Please contact webmaster if you have problems seeing this image code Load New Code
 
        
Blog Archive
 
2010
   

IN PURSUIT OF FAME

THE CURIOUS APPEAL OF SALMAN KHAN

THE RISE OF $ BILLIONAIRES

THE RIGHT TO PRIVACY

THE DEFICIT OF TRUST

A NATION OF BANS

LEARNING TO SAY SORRY

A BANDH THAT WORKED

THE MAKING OF GOTHAM CITY

THE PRICE OF HONESTY

LEARNING STARTS WITH IRREVERENCE

The Power of No

THE AGE OF THE FORGETTABLE

A VERDICT FOR CHANGE

THE IRRELEVANCE OF THE BJP

FOLLOW THE MONEY!

WHERE HAVE ALL THE GOOD GUYS GONE?

WILL THE NET DISTORT HISTORY?

THE BLINDING POWER OF BLACK

THE WONDERLAND THAT'S INDIA

THE POWER OF CONTROVERSY

THE BUDGET AS TAMASHA

THE GIFTING OF LOVE

THE RHETORIC OF CHANGE

THE IMPORTANCE OF AWARDS

RENEWING THE CHASE FOR EXCELLENCE

The Art of Living

MYSTIQUE OF THE WHITE SHIRT
   
2009
   

EXIT, THE TALL, DARK, HANDSOME STRANGER

FLEEING THE PRISON OF TECHNOLOGY

LET’S GET BACK TO MAKING MOVIES

The Murder of a Sportsman

LETTERS, TWEETS, ONE PAISA SMS

LET’S STOP JABBERING ABOUT 26/11

WELCOME TO THE AGE OF EXCESS

WHO IS A HERO?

WHAT IS STAR POWER?

WHY STABILITY HAS AN EDGE OVER CHANGE

THE CHOICES WE MAKE

THE ART OF MANAGING FAME

WHY DO WE WANT OUR LEADERS TO BE SO BORING?

THE INQUISITIVE INDIAN

WORDS DIE. SO DO MOST THINGS

THE NEW POLITICS OF AUSTERITY

DO WE ALL HAVE A SELL-BY DATE?

THE POWER OF BREVITY

DOES GOOD STAND A CHANCE AT ALL?

THE PHATAPHAT GENERATION

MORNING SICKNESS NOW HITS US ALL

THE ONLY GENIUS I EVER KNEW

A FREE NATION IS UNAFRAID TO LIVE OUT ITS DREAMS

THE INDISCREET ART OF DADAGIRI

TRUTH OR DARE?

WELCOME TO THE AGE OF BLACKMAIL

END OF A ROMANCE

A CHANGING WORLD ORDER?

EXIT THE COMMISSARS

DID WE ACTUALLY VOTE FOR CHANGE?

HYSTERIA IS NO ANSWER TO TERRORISM

A NEW DEAL IN THE NEW YEAR?
   
2008
   

WHAT SHALL WE REMEMBER 26/11 FOR?
GRIEF, ANGER, OR CHANGE?

IS THIS THE CHANGE WE ASKED FOR?

GET THESE NETAS OFF OUR BACK!

THE KILLER APPEAL OF BAD BOY MARKETING

THE PLAUSIBILITY OF HOPE

THE ART OF INTOLERANCE

WAITING FOR A MIRACLE

PAPA DON'T PREACH

FIVE BLIND MEN AND MY HINDOOSTAN

THE ART OF THE CON

DO WE REALLY KNOW HOW TO FIGHT TERRORISM?

TIME TO REJECT OLD PLATITUDES

WAITING FOR A MIRACLE

LIVING ON THE EDGE

MANMOHAN SINGH'S LAST CHANCE

NOT JUST INFLATION, A NIGHTMARE

TIME FOR ANGER MANAGEMENT

THE LEGEND OF CHE

A STAR IS A STAR, NOT SUPERMAN

WINNING IS NOT ABOUT MONEY

LET'S LOOK FOR EASIER SOLUTIONS

SOFT POWER UNITES WHAT POLITICS DIVIDES

TIME TO SIGN THE NUCLEAR DEAL

A PIRATED COPY OF FREE INDIA

TOO MUCH TAMASHA KILLS THE GAME

IPL AND A THROWBACK TO OLD LOYALTIES

THE MOCKERY OF FIGHTING INFLATION

LET'S CATCH CRIMINALS, NOT JUDGE THEIR VICTIMS

THE POLITICS OF PROFLIGACY

APNA SAPNA MONEY MONEY

THE TRAGEDY OF REGIONAL POLITICS

WHY TAX PAYERS HATE PAYING TAXES

LOSING BY THE RULE BOOK
   
2007
   

WINNING IS EVERYTHING:

CHANGING STATUS SYMBOLS BY PRITISH NANDY

WHY TASLIMA NEEDS YOUR SUPPORT BY PRITISH NANDY

INDIA NEEDS THREE CRICKET TEAMS by PRITISH NANDY

STEP OUT OF THE PANIC ROOM OF THE PRESENT

PRITISH NANDY'S BEST INTERVIEW EVER

THIS NONSENSE ABOUT BIG FILMS